Defining ‘Good’ Literature
I’m preparing a power point presentation for a series of sessions at NCTM meetings this autumn. My session is: Stories that Count: Literature in the Math Classroom.
In choosing books to include in the session, I have 2 caveats:
-
All books aren’t meant for mathematics. Books shouldn’t be “twisted” in order to suit math instruction purposes. If we want to use literature as a way to give math meaning, the books we choose should contain good, relevant math.
-
We must choose good literature. If we introduce children to a book, let’s make it a good book!
The seminal ideas of math are rather easily defined; NCTM standards detail content to be mastered at each grade level. The second admonition is, perhaps, more perilous. What are the characteristics of good literature?
I have several ideas, but they’re mine:
-
Good literature should keep you interested and entertained.
-
It should have a theme: It should be funny or sad or suspenseful or….
-
It should have a certain universal appeal and be able to withstand the test of time.
-
And (this is a pet peeve) children’s literature should be well written. Books, at this stage, form a building block of language; grammar, syntax, meter, etc., become important examples.
I also offer these quotes:
“My definition of good literature is that which can be read by an educated reader, and reread with increased pleasure.” Gene Wolfe
(Goodnight Moon; Somebody Loves You, Mr. Hatch: “Read it again, Mommy.” )
“A true classic has enriched the human mind, increased its treasure, and caused it to advance a step.” Charles Augustin Sainte-Beuve
(The Giving Tree)
But these are only my thoughts. I’d really enjoy hearing other ideas. Anyone have some to share?

September 15th, 2009 at 6:18 pm
I’m still in the process of preparing my sessions and had a thought sent to me from one of the very best writers (who I an lucky enough to know as a friend).
Children’s poet Eileen Spinelli wrote:
My thought about good literature: Good literature changes my heart…changes my life. Not always in a big way…but always in some way.
Eileen always gets to the ‘heart’ of it.
Marianne